The Joy Of Editing? Skip This Step for A Mediocre Book
Happy New Year! I pray this is the year you get your project across the finish line. If it’s a book, read on!
Why do we write books? I heard a great answer to this question the other day on Cary Niehoff’s podcast with Seth Godin. Seth, big thinker and author of 21 international best sellers said:
“The purpose of a book is to change your mind.”
That sums it up nicely, but I would add that a great book transforms the heart. It can change the whole trajectory of a person’s life. I’m assuming that is your goal.
While l love the way I’ve described the book-writing process in my book: From Heart to Page: A Short Book on Writing Your Christian Book, I’ve been doing a short series here on a 5 step process. I hope it has been helpful.
The 5-step book plan is:
- Lay a Foundation
- Develop a Clear Outline
- Write with Purpose
- Polish and Refine
- Publish and Promote
You’ve read and applied Step 1 and Step 2, and Step 3. You have a manuscript. Well done!
Now it is time to polish and refine it.
Step 4: Polish and Refine
Once your manuscript is complete, the real craft begins. This is where you take your raw material and shape it into a book that’s clear, compelling, and ready for your audience. Refining your manuscript is about turning your words into a polished, transformative experience for your readers.
Here’s a detailed look at the essential editing passes that will help you refine your book for clarity, consistency, and spiritual impact. Along the way, I’ll share insights I’ve learned not only from my experience but also from the incredibly good book by AJ Harper, who is an expert in reader-focused writing. Get her book, Write a Must Read, if you don’t have it. She’s the best there is.
The Important Editing Passes for Your Manuscript
1. The Structural Edit
This is your big-picture pass. Does the manuscript flow logically? Are there gaps in the argument, story, or theology? This pass ensures that the foundation of your book is solid and aligned with your purpose.
From AJ Harper: I learned the importance of always writing with the reader in mind.
Ask yourself: What does my reader need next? Every chapter should serve the ultimate promise of the book, creating a logical and emotionally resonant path.
2. The Content Edit
This pass is about refining your message for clarity, depth, and tone. Does the book communicate your central idea? Are your biblical references accurate and impactful? Refine each chapter to ensure it aligns with the overarching goal.
Cut anything that doesn’t serve the reader. As AJ says, “Write the book that changes lives.” If a section or story doesn’t move your reader closer to their desired outcome, remove it—even if you love it.
3. The Voice and Style Edit
This is where you make sure the manuscript reflects your authentic voice while resonating with your target audience. Is the tone warm and engaging? For a Christian book, balance truth, grace, and relatability.
Be intentional about crafting a voice that feels conversational. AJ emphasizes building trust with your reader through consistency in tone and by speaking directly to their concerns.
4. The Biblical Scripture Edit
As a Christian writer, it’s crucial to ensure that your Scripture references are accurate and contextually appropriate. Misapplying Scripture can undermine your credibility.
Here’s what to check:
•Are your verses quoted correctly?
•Do they align with your theological argument?
•Does the chosen translation resonate with your audience?
AJ Harper isn’t writing about biblical books, but if she did, she’d say: Cross-reference your scriptures with your central promise. Ask, Does this verse deepen the reader’s understanding of God or faith? Ensure every passage ties back to your core message.
5. The Spiritual Edit
This is a unique and prayerful step. Ask God to reveal areas that need refining. Pray over your manuscript and ask, Is this faithful to God’s message? Does this glorify Him and help readers grow closer to Christ?
While AJ’s process is deeply reader-focused, I adapted her principles to include spiritual sensitivity and God-focus. Pray not just for clarity but for discernment to highlight what God wants emphasized and to remove what distracts from His message.
6. The Line Edit (Or Copy Edit)
Once the structure is in place, read every line. Is it written in the best possible way? It could be helpful to have someone else do this. Hire a professional editor who understands your voice, but is great at writing with clarity.
Harper stresses that every sentence should contribute to the reader’s understanding of the material. Line editing is where you ensure that your writing is free of unnecessary complexity.
•Simplify overly long or complicated sentences.
•Avoid jargon, especially if it alienates or confuses readers.
•Make sure transitions between sentences are seamless.
7. The Reader Experience Edit
AJ Harper taught me the value of walking in your reader’s shoes. Though I try to do that from the beginning, this edit involves reading your manuscript as if you were encountering it for the first time.
Ask yourself:
•Is the book’s promise clear from the start?
•Are there moments where the reader might get confused or bored?
•Does the manuscript consistently deliver what the reader truly needs?
This pass ensures you’re meeting—and exceeding—your reader’s expectations.
8. The Final Proofread
Focus on typos, formatting, and consistency. This is your last pass before publication to ensure that everything looks polished and professional.
For my own process at ChristianGhostwriting.com I have a brilliant team and will generally have 3-4 different people go through it at this stage. Technology is good here too.
Your book has the power to change minds, touch hearts, and point people toward the truth. That’s worth taking the time to get it right.
Next week, we’ll talk publishing and promotion.
Let’s make this the year you not only finish your book but prepare it to make the impact it’s meant to have. I’m praying for you right now as I write.
Happy New Year, and happy writing
